View Item 
  •   Boyce Digital Repository Home
  • Dissertations, Theses, and Projects
  • Open Access Dissertations and Theses
  • View Item
  •   Boyce Digital Repository Home
  • Dissertations, Theses, and Projects
  • Open Access Dissertations and Theses
  • View Item
JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

Browse

All Digital CollectionsCommunities & CollectionsBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsThis CollectionBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjects

Peter Singer's proposed value of the "person" in "Rethinking Life and Death": A critical evaluation

Thumbnail
View/Open
3148550.pdf (6.487Mb)
Date
2004-09-28
Author
Johnson, Jerry Allen
Advisor
Cook, E. David
Metadata
Show full item record
Subject
Singer, Peter. Rethinking life and death : the collapse of our traditional ethics
Abortion--Moral and ethical aspects
Euthenasia--Moral and ethical aspects
Life and death, Power over--Moral and ethical aspects
Medical ethics
Bioethics
Abstract
This dissertation examines Peter Singer's proposed ethical value of the "person" in Rethinking Life and Death . Chapter 1 introduces and outlines Singer's proposal, which argues for abortion, infanticide, euthanasia, and assisted suicide. His proposal consists of four key points. First, there is the foundation for his proposal--rejecting creation for evolution. Second, there is the substance of his proposal--replacing the value of the "human" with the value of the "person." Third, there is the criteria for his proposal--using "indicators" and "relevant characteristics" to identify the kinds of beings who qualify as "persons." Fourth, there are the consequences of his proposal--promising an ethical "Copernican Revolution." Chapters 2-5 critically evaluate the four key ideas from Singer above. The evaluation of the respective key idea in each chapter covers five steps: (1) the context of Singer's proposal; (2) the content of Singer's proposal; (3) positive evaluation; (4) negative critique; and (5) conclusion. The research methodology for the dissertation is to treat Singer's ethical proposal on the "person" as a hypothesis to be tested by his own truth standards of logical consistency, empirical evidence, and practicality. Following these four key chapters, Chapter 6 provides "Summary and Conclusions." The conclusion of this dissertation is that Peter Singer's proposal on life and death is not to be commended because its key elements are not supported by his own standards for testing truth. In fact, when examined by his own truth tests, Singer's program should be rejected because its foundation is faulty, its substance is illusory, its criteria are circular, and its consequences would be grave.
URI
http://hdl.handle.net/10392/272
Collections
  • Open Access Dissertations and Theses

Related items

Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.

  • Ethics A-Team 

    Sanderson, Carla; Thobaben, Jim; Land, Richard (1998-02-28)
  • The impact of the biblical principles of community and honor on the problem of ageism in quality-adjusted life years 

    Kelly, Brent Robert (Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, 2004-12-06)
    This thesis examines the problem of utilitarian ageism in Quality-Adjusted Life Years and contrasts it with the biblical principles of community and honor that are to characterize treatment of the elderly. Chapter 1 provides ...
  • The Christian Challenge in a Decadent Age 

    Mohler, R. Albert (1997-03-03)
    A Christian Life Commission seminar. Seminar theme: 50 years and coming ... cherishing our past, charting our future.

DSpace software copyright © 2002-2025  DuraSpace
Contact Us | Send Feedback
DSpace Express is a service operated by 
Atmire NV